- Not to be confused with Lieutenant Benedict.
Benedict, a member of the Bloodhill Bandits, tried to rob Arthas near a village between the Silver Hand encampment and Strahnbrad by luring him into a trap. He was disguised as a villager and asked for help, but when Arthas approached, he and four bandits attacked Arthas' forces. Arthas and his footmen killed him and his bandits.
Upon his death he dropped a Scroll of Healing.
- Benedict: Save us!
- Benedict (bandit): Get them!
- Footman: It's a trap!
- Benedict (bandit): Take everything, men. Take all the valuables.
His name is a possible reference to Benedict Arnold, a famous turncoat during the American Revolution; this is supported considering he is disguised as an ally at first, eventually turning on Arthas and his men.