of the Nightfall is a title awarded when you complete the achievement  [The Twilight Zone (10 player)], slaying Sartharion the Onyx Guardian in the Obsidian Sanctum of the Chamber of Aspects on normal difficulty with all three Twilight Drakes still alive.

The title will appear after the player's name:

<Name> of the Nightfall

v • d • e Player character titles Arena Vanquisher · Gladiator (Merciless, Vengeful, Brutal, Deadly, Furious, Relentless, Wrathful) · Duelist · Rival · Challenger · Flawless Victor · Arena Master Rated Battlegrounds Warbound · Hero of the Alliance · Veteran of the Alliance · Warbringer · Hero of the Horde · Veteran of the Horde Rated Battleground Rating Private · Corporal · Sergeant · Master Sergeant · Sergeant Major · Knight · Knight-Lieutenant · Knight-Captain · Knight-Champion · Lieutenant Commander · Commander · Marshal · Field Marshal · Grand Marshal Rated Battleground Rating Scout · Grunt · Sergeant · Senior Sergeant · First Sergeant · Stone Guard · Blood Guard · Legionnaire · Centurion · Champion · Lieutenant General · General · Warlord · High Warlord Battlegrounds Conqueror · Justicar · Battlemaster Exploration the Explorer Feats of Strength PvE Bloodsail Admiral · Scarab Lord · Champion of the Naaru · Hand of A'dal · Conqueror of Naxxramas · Obsidian Slayer · the Magic Seeker · the Celestial Defender · Death's Demise · Grand Crusader Arena Gladiator (Merciless, Vengeful, Brutal, Deadly, Furious, Relentless, Wrathful) · Vanquisher Honor System Private · Corporal · Sergeant · Master Sergeant · Sergeant Major · Knight · Knight-Lieutenant · Knight-Captain · Knight-Champion · Lieutenant Commander · Commander · Marshal · Field Marshal · Grand Marshal Honor System Scout · Grunt · Sergeant · Senior Sergeant · First Sergeant · Stone Guard · Blood Guard · Legionnaire · Centurion · Champion · Lieutenant General · General · Warlord · High Warlord Professions Chef  · Salty PvE Jenkins · the Patient · Champion of the Frozen Wastes · the Undying · of the Nightfall · the Immortal · Twilight Vanquisher · Champion of Ulduar · Conqueror of Ulduar · Starcaller · Herald of the Titans · the Astral Walker · Argent Defender · the Kingslayer · Bane of the Fallen King · The Light of Dawn · Blackwing's Bane · Dragonslayer · of the Four Winds · Defender of a Shattered World PvP of the Alliance · of the Horde · the Bloodthristy Quests the Seeker · Loremaster Reputation the Exalted · Ambassador · Guardian of Cenarius · the Argent Champion · the Diplomat · of the Shattered Sun · the Insane · of the Ashen Verdict World Events Elder · the Love Fool · the Noble · Matron · Patron · Flame Keeper · Flame Warden · Brewmaster · the Hallowed · the Pilgrim · the Merrymaker Argent Tournament of Darnassus · of the Exodar · of Gnomeregan · of Ironforge · of Stormwind · of Orgrimmar · of Sen'jin · of Silvermoon · of Thunder Bluff · of the Undercity · Crusader