Here is a chart of the buffs with answers you need to give to get them.
NOTE: Upon entering TK raid instance this buff disappeared for me and some others. Be warned it may do it for others, but more testing is needed. Tested in SSC - Buff vanishes non entry. Seems like a non-raid buff. Possibly works for PVP. (Buff also vanishes when entering ICC.)
Buff Received
Effect
Answer to Question 1
Answer to Question 2
Sayge's Dark Fortune of Damage
Increases all damage by 1 to 10%.
1
1
Sayge's Dark Fortune of Resistance
1
2
Sayge's Dark Fortune of Armor
1
3
Sayge's Dark Fortune of Spirit
2
1
Sayge's Dark Fortune of Intelligence
2
2
Sayge's Dark Fortune of Resistance
2
3
Sayge's Dark Fortune of Stamina
Increases Stamina by 10%
3
1
Sayge's Dark Fortune of Strength
3
2
Sayge's Dark Fortune of Agility
3
3
Sayge's Dark Fortune of Intelligence
4
1
Sayge's Dark Fortune of Spirit
4
2
Sayge's Dark Fortune of Armor
4
3
Here are the results based on the following answers:
1. "Slay the Man" (+Damage, +Magic Resist, or +Armor)
1. +1 to 10% Damage - Sayge's Dark Fortune of Damage
1st: Slay the Man
2nd: Execute your friend painfully
2. +25 All Resistances - Sayge's Dark Fortune of Resistance
1st: Slay the Man
2nd: Execute your friend painlessly
3. +10% Armor - Sayge's Dark Fortune of Armor
1st: Slay the Man
2nd: Let your friend go
2. "Turn him over to liege" (+Spirit, +Intellect, or +Magic Resist)
1. +10% Spirit - Sayge's Dark Fortune of Spirit
1st: Turn him over to liege
2nd: Confront the diplomat
2. +10% Intellect - Sayge's Dark Fortune of Intelligence
1st: Turn him over to liege
2nd: Show not so quiet defiance
3. +25 All Resistances - Sayge's Dark Fortune of Resistance
1st: Turn him over to liege
2nd: Remain quiet
3. "Confiscate the corn" (+Stamina, +Strength, or +Agility)
1. +10% Stamina - Sayge's Dark Fortune of Stamina
1st: Confiscate the corn
2nd: Speak against your brother openly
2. +10% Strength - Sayge's Dark Fortune of Strength
1st: Confiscate the corn
2nd: Help your brother in
3. +10% Agility - Sayge's Dark Fortune of Agility
1st: Confiscate the Corn
2nd: Keep your brother out without letting him know
4. "Let him go and have the corn" (+Intellect, +Spirit, or +Armor)
1. +10% Intellect - Sayge's Dark Fortune of Intelligence
1st: Let him go and have the corn
2nd: Take credit, keep gold
2. +10% Spirit - Sayge's Dark Fortune of Spirit
1st: Let him go and have the corn
2nd: Take credit, share the gold
3. +10% Armor - Sayge's Dark Fortune of Armor
1st: Let him go and have the corn
2nd: Let the knight take credit
Text of the Fortunes
Example fortune from Sayge
When you answer Sayge's questions and receive the buff, you will receive a fortune item in your inventory with a random saying upon it. Most of these items are for flavor and humor only and can be safely discarded. A few of the items will start a quest if you right click on them.
Below is a list of the sayings found on each fortune. If the given item starts a quest, it is noted here as well.[1][2]
Sayge's Fortune #1: "Never eat beef with a tauren."
Sayge's Fortune #2: "You will find something wonderful tomorrow."
Sayge's Fortune #3: "An enemy from your past will soon become an ally."
Sayge's Fortune #4: "You will be fortunate in everything you put your hands to."
Sayge's Fortune #5: "Someone is speaking well of you."
Sayge's Fortune #6: "Be cautious when landing in unfamiliar territory."
Sayge's Fortune #28: "Hunters who specialize in survival are not guaranteed to survive."
Sayge's Fortune #29: "Look out!"
Trivia
Sayge is an homage to the classic Ultima series of role playing games. In Ultima IV, V, VI and IX, the game began with a meeting with The Gypsy fortune teller, and your answers to her moral dilemmas determined the stats your character would begin with.