December 2011 UpdateEdit
I updated my own server page and decided to take a look at other pages in my battlegroup, since I've probably run into the general population before as both Darrowmere Horde and Vashj Alliance.
I felt that this page needed a general statistics update and quite honestly, a less 'bitter Alliance' flavor, as well as a good deal of wikification.
The changes made to the guild lists are meant to reflect the most current statistics: - PVE guilds that are actively progressing in 4.3 content - PVP guilds with an end season rating > 1000 - Leveling guilds with a lead in overall guild activity, but without end game progression in this expansion.
If you feel your guild was overlooked, particularly in regard to the Alliance here (I feel for you, it's why I left Vashj), I don't claim to be an authority in any capacity on this server. The lists as they were had not been updated since Wrath.